K-12 safety plans, explained for families and staff
← All posts

ALICE vs. “I Love U Guys”: Two School Safety Plans, Different Words

Some schools teach ALICE. Others use the “I Love U Guys” Standard Response Protocol, and many use both. Here is how the words line up and what each one asks students and staff to do.

If one school talks about “ALICE” and another talks about “I Love U Guys,” it can sound like two completely different plans. They overlap more than the names suggest. The biggest difference is what each one is built to cover.

We’re not picking a sideSchool Safety Plainly isn’t recommending one program over the other or saying one is better. This post simply shows you the different options, how their words line up, and what each one asks people to do, so you can understand the plan your school uses.

Two programs, two jobs

The Standard Response Protocol (SRP) comes from the nonprofit “I Love U Guys” Foundation. It gives schools five actions for any emergency, from a medical call in the hallway to a tornado: Hold, Secure, Lockdown, Evacuate and Shelter. Each action is announced with a short directive, so students, staff and first responders all hear the same words [1][2].

ALICE Training comes from the company Navigate360. Its five letters stand for Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter and Evacuate. They are options for one situation, an armed intruder or other violent threat, and they aren’t steps to follow in order. People use whichever ones fit what is happening [3][4].

How the words line up

SituationSRP (“I Love U Guys”)ALICE (Navigate360)
Keep the halls clear, such as during a medical callHold: “In your room or area.”No matching term
Danger outside the buildingSecure: “Get inside. Lock outside doors.”No matching term. Many schools call this a lockout.
Danger inside the buildingLockdown: “Locks, lights, out of sight.”Lockdown, plus barricading the door
Spreading the wordThe action and its directive are announcedAlert, then Inform: live updates on where the threat is
Leaving the buildingEvacuate: “To a location.”Evacuate when it’s safe, away from the threat
Severe weather or a chemical spillShelter: the hazard and safety strategy are statedNot covered. ALICE is for violent threats.
An intruder reaches the roomNot one of the five actionsCounter: noise, movement and distraction, as a last resort

SRP used to call its “Secure” action “Lockout.” The Foundation changed the name in 2020, so older posters and handouts may still use the old word [2].

The biggest difference: what happens in a lockdown

In an SRP lockdown, students move out of sight, stay quiet and don’t open the door. Staff lock the door, turn off the lights and wait for first responders [2].

ALICE calls its version an “enhanced” lockdown. Staff lock the door, barricade it with whatever is in the room, and get ready to leave or counter if the situation changes. ALICE also leans more on people making their own choices based on what they can see and hear [3].

What “Counter” means

Counter is the part of ALICE that families ask about most. Navigate360 describes it as a last resort that uses noise, movement and distraction to throw off an intruder, and it says Counter isn’t the same as fighting. Its school materials are adjusted for students’ age and developmental level, so what a kindergartner practices looks very different from what a high schooler learns [3].

For familiesIf your school teaches ALICE, ask what your child’s grade actually practices. For young children, the answer is usually much simpler than the name suggests.

Who runs each program

The “I Love U Guys” Foundation offers SRP materials at no cost to schools [1]. ALICE is taught through Navigate360’s training program, which combines online lessons, in-person sessions and a certified instructor course [3].

One, the other or both

The two programs don’t really compete. SRP gives everyone, from kindergartners to first responders, the same words for every kind of emergency. ALICE focuses on choices during a violent intruder. Some districts use SRP for announcements and posters and add options-based training so staff know what to do if a lockdown isn’t enough. Others use one program, or a plan of their own.

Students with disabilitiesAsk how the plan works for your child. A good plan accounts for students who use a wheelchair, can’t hear an announcement, or may struggle to stay quiet or still.

What to ask your school

  • Which plan do you use: SRP, ALICE, both or your own?
  • What words will my child hear over the announcement system?
  • What does my child’s grade practice during a lockdown drill?
  • How does the plan include students with disabilities?
  • How will you tell families what is happening during an emergency?

Sources

  1. The Standard Response Protocol (SRP) (The "I Love U Guys" Foundation)
  2. SRP K12 Operational Guidance (The "I Love U Guys" Foundation)
  3. The Ultimate Guide to ALICE Training for Schools (Navigate360)
  4. Situational Awareness (Navigate360 ALICE Training)

SRP and The Standard Response Protocol are trademarks of The “I Love U Guys” Foundation. ALICE Training is a registered trademark of Navigate360. This post compares the programs for families and isn’t affiliated with or endorsed by either organization.

This post is general information. Your school's own plan comes first, so ask the school office for its specific procedures.